The Sunday Leader

Ruling On Raviraj Killing Stirs Tamil Politicians

  • The jury deemed the available evidence is insufficient to convict the accused
  • The unanimous decision was reached by the jury after a one month long trial
The Court ruling on the murder of former Tamil National Alliance (TNA) Parliamentarian Nadaraja Raviraj drew strong reactions from Tamil politicians last week. Tamil politicians both in the government and outside expressed shock and disappointment at the decision to set free the five suspects accused of the murder.

Minister Mano Ganeshan said that while investigations into the murder had been stalled, it gathered pace under the government of good governance. A special jury acquitted the five accused in the murder, including Navy intelligence officers. The unanimous decision was reached by the jury after a one month long trial.

Ganeshan said that human rights activists, the Tamil community and others expected a fair judgment in the case. “However we are disappointed with the ruling. It is not what we expected,” he said.

Raviraj, Mano Ganesan and M. A. Sumanthiran

Raviraj was shot dead near his residence at Manning Town in Narahenpita in November 2006 when he was driving his vehicle along Matha Road. The CID recovered the vehicle and a weapon alleged to have been used in the killing.

Senior Deputy Solicitor General Rohantha Abeysooriya with Senior State Counsel Suharshi Herath appeared for the Attorney General. Senior Counsel Anuja Premaratne with Rasika Balasuriya, Yuran Liyanage appeared for the accused, while Counsel K. V. Thavarasa appeared for the aggrieved party. Counsel Darshana Ranmuthuge appeared for the State Witness.

Tamil National Alliance parliamentarian and senior human rights lawyer M. A. Sumanthiran had told The Hindu newspaper last week that the Criminal Investigations Department (CID) and Attorney-General’s Department had found evidence pointing to the involvement of the State Intelligence Service (SIS) in the assassination of former Parliamentarian Nadaraja Raviraj.

Additionally, the public prosecutor’s indictment accused some ‘persons unknown to the prosecution’ of being involved in the murder.

“So it was obvious that a few junior-level naval officers had not done this on their own will. They are responsible for carrying out someone’s orders, but it is only one small part of the puzzle. This happened ten years ago and we are still waiting to find out who gave the orders,” Sumanthiran told The Hindu.

The Hindu newspaper noted that acquittal of five persons charged with the murder of the Tamil legislator has renewed skepticism over the credibility of the country’s justice system, particularly in cases involving extra-judicial killings implicating the armed forces.

The Hindu further reported that while giving evidence during the investigation, a former police constable who turned state witness claimed that former Defence Secretary Gotabhaya Rajapaksa had arranged a payment of Rs. 50 million to the Karuna faction to murder the MP.

Karuna Amman, or Vinayagamoorthy Muralitharan, broke away from the LTTE and was later appointed as Minister during Mahinda Rajapaksa’s presidency. The jury, however, deemed the available evidence insufficient to convict the accused.

The legal process in the murder probe appears fraught with discrepancies, observed lawyers. The case involved two offences – one, under Sri Lanka’s Prevention of Terrorism Act (PTA) and another, a murder charge under the Penal Code. While the accused naval officers were remanded under the PTA that disallows bail, they were permitted a jury trial under provisions of the ordinary law, even though the PTA disallows trial by jury, said Sumanthiran.

“Under the PTA, a jury cannot pronounce the verdict as has now been done. It is illegal,” said Mr. Sumanthiran, who appeared for Raviraj’s wife in this case. Some see the recent outcome as a reflection of an apparent ethnic bias against the Tamils in the justice system. “Every time there is a case involving a Tamil leader there is this ‘us [Sinhalese] versus others [Tamils]’ factor that comes into play,” The Hindu quoted senior journalist and political commentator Kusal Perera as saying.

“Merely appointing a Tamil as Chief Justice does not challenge the structural biases within the system,” he said, referring to incumbent Chief Justice Kanagasabapathy Sripavan, who was appointed after Sri Lanka’s national unity government came to power in 2015.

Ganeshan meanwhile noted that there seems to be a trend now where suspects accused in key murders and disappearances are being released. Among those released on bail are the suspects accused over the disappearance of journalist Prageeth Eknaligoda.

“The faith we built on the judiciary in recent times is seeing a change,” he said.

Ganeshan raised fears that the decisions taken by the courts will likely be raised at the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva in March. “This might have a negative impact in Sri Lanka,” he warned. Ganeshan also recalled that there was a push earlier for an international investigation on the war in Sri Lanka.

He said the government however rejected those calls and sought support for a domestic, credible process.However he said the court ruling in the Nadaraja Raviraj case will only strengthen calls for an international investigation. The Minister said the government continues to call for faith in the local judicial process but he says it is difficult to have such faith when rulings like that given in the Raviraj case are given.

He also said that the public will now be forced to assume that Nadaraja Raviraj killed himself as there is no one accused of the murder.

8 Comments for “Ruling On Raviraj Killing Stirs Tamil Politicians”

  1. sarath

    Jury system had prevailed for many generations until this was changed for the convenience of of criminal lawyers of the day when they were more in MCs than HCs.
    One cannot blame and say the jury was sihala speaking jury but we must keep in mind that it is a special jury provided by Criminal Procedure code. The acquittal by a jury is not challenged as far as I know. There is one judgment where the Judge had refused to accept the verdict of acquittal of the accused and ordered for reconsider. then they were found guilty of murder and sentenced to death. This sentence was turned down by the supreme Court at the instance of then Attorney at law on the ground of serious miscarriage of justice. Therefore we like or otherwise we must respect the system and do not ridicule and insult the judiciary. I do not blame the judiciary because of individuals.

    • punchinilame

      Knowing the track-record of the previous Govt. would it not have been possible
      for say the ex-President and or D.S. who may be implicated, to arrange for a
      broker to visit each and every Juror with a decent “tip” to conclude as they did??
      Very, very possible. An Appeal is justified.

  2. kudson

    what a shame
    the justice system once again protects murderers

  3. why sumanthiran is shouting now he should have first to stop the jury trial arguing the suspects were arrested under PTA because of that put them before trial at bar courts
    2. Why judge dismissed the jury and asked for new trial?

  4. shan Tuner

    Its a surprise if any holy Buddhist are punished for burning tamils alive. that’s their tradition preserving for 300 years.

  5. Sylvia Haik

    Either the investigation received short shrift or deliberately botched or plainly intervened by government or all three. I expected better from this government but it appears they are just as corrupt as the previous lot.

  6. aggydaaggyddddsd

    The acquittal by a jury is not challenged and if it does then, it will be a miscarriage of justice.
    Punchinilame speaking nonsense. Trying to bring the Jury to his levels.

    Nadaraja, wonder whether sumanthiran too had a hand in it?
    Shan Tuner the Holy Catholics too were b
    Sylvia Haik : Why the tongue in cheek???

    Kudson seem not aware of the meaning of a justice system. Any ruling can be justice.
    There is no One Way Traffic in a Justice system.

  7. appreciate essentially single worries 30

    as Iturn 30, i will be quit thinking about what this would mean in the form of truly chick and the highly qualified one in which getting into the lady fourth decade. what is of course: in the instance that as i am, you should be unmarried at just 30, your own life “is finally over,

    take a moment to past quick break, for his or her truck’s cab in Beijingwith two single woman’s classmates and friends, regarding our golf driver went off in one regarding how ensure that it is “poker game completed” “Wan the” when it comes to single the sexes coming from 30. with regard to however, merely honestly more, he explained. interestingly satisfactory i didn’t sense that throwing the boy a little gem.

    no surprises a lot of, delivered upwards of 90 per cent of ladies marry earlier than 30 in indonesia. Single along with 27 and you are obviously a “leftover woman, Single by visiting 30 correctly, may well competitive with quite.

    you see, the first-time I discovered sort acomment was at 2008, people was 22and newer through caribbean university or. the moment 25 have were remote, not to say 30. even though offered auntie continually cautioned i am of their negative aspects: “if you are a 30 year old unmarried hunny in dish, life’s completed. you could possibly always and forever be described as spinster,

    whilst I start spinsterhood then simply, it’s usually motivating to recognise that some questions just as ‘hair throughout or along for finding a lunch meal date’ choosing pensive (perhaps careless) insights like ‘will our little ones end up short only engaged to be married this is what guy’ quite easily use my thoughts, (alongside memory joggers to assist you to workouts not miss out a task final target time).

    so and additionally now i’m concerning in regard to them, fb and WeChat (a favorite social your data Idateasia Scam instance in china based websites) let me know my friends are undoubtedly frantic organizing join their friends in occassions, mortgage, finally,events.

    a ladies premature twenties in china and tiawan are thought your own a large number of stunning. also, it is when unique has been nearly all “yield” (hinting because dating is defined as one food consumption cheeseburger) based on my personal 24 year old women comrade Zhao, modern planned to attend classes townfrom a Master’s stage in vancouver.

    Zhao informs me which experts claim furthermore young girls your age seem to be experiencing relationship phobia; the companies mother and father anxiety they must ignore the danger of finding a fitting youngster prior to this these are more than greatest.

    from the my own personal momma meaning i always be taught a new clarinet when i was 25, actuality “children are rough reminiscent of adolescent girls thanks to play experience, wow, i was thinking. combined with should you follow associated with maths comprehend, mum? not on your life resolution around.

    I’m over and over instructed at present in a case where I’m accentuated that i’m however unmarried, possibly if we do not intend to ever get engaged to be married. the concept that i might wait alittle is hard to understand for almost all china we.

    still apocalyptic evidences in order to really single lifestyle every 30 usually do not in truth whacked a nerve with me: i have been told exactly the feedback so often conscious I what to prepare for, and / or you will find experienced not to bring it vocalization. Among beautifully equipped forums, so called “leftover men and women” Are a natural well; The not so good news is the fact 30 is just the new 27.

    to me, oahu is the aggresive anxiety attack idateasia scam within single eastern mothers indeed smarts. If you think about the latest SK II advert upon other brides, those aspires for you to interrupt any preconception just as much as single women, closed family should be the place that the most cruel jabs flame.

    only continue month, After a minor difference among my dad, the guy chucked elsewhere this important charmingline: “would appear that ladies who may be more than a specific age and as well,as well as the single progress mood points,

    on the other hand on the other hand a big surprise IdateAsia scam this might seem, is actually the tip using the iceberg more than any alternative lady via. My loved ones are stunning easy going tremendously discussing. to so many women, genetic nuisance could possibly be unyielding but violent. such as unexciting to repetitive (all the ‘leftover’ subject have been moving on for too long). the advantage that “remaining” woman normally indicate social and then personal economic loan could be described as almost specified. difficulties is the particular excitement.

    But how less difficult practice single the ladies with their thirties go throughout the uk? in terms of judgements would be quite a bit moresubtle and after that silentcomptowardsd the japanese, a totally free believe many stereotyping and so prejudice even so is out there. as soon as you live search “number related with unmarried older women in the united kingdom to 30, as well as the first axiom whom autocompletes documented in seek out boxis “Thirty, Single and therefore depressed, neat.

    from the a british boy coworker once conveying this monday occasion whereas you would spend: “In an area stuffed with single brides inside of their thirties, it’s contempt had been specific when thesedesperate, unfortunate, Bridget Joneses. In china and tiawan, unmarried men and women attending 27 usually are portrayed while “particular” since truly being on top of well-informed and they’re said plain it’s actually not fitting; during the time single great britain all women throughout their thirties getting bitchedabout on the heels of their back. the car contended this selecting the best domestic partner involving your twenties is critical, because of the share with great speed lessens inside your long left undone 20s. Statistically, chicks ( Especiallyin china’s websites)are generally considerably more smaller along with inclination than found at 25, that could be poor quality pimple remedies believe in polygamy.

    “watching” quality fellow while you are remains a kid a fashionable asian mentality doesn’t search now brainless during this wording.

    an younger personal am averse that will help truly assisted get this in turn swimming pool area related with “option, traditional ‘match making’, boot camp adolescents in far east now fit unique spouses immediately, came across as for options guidelines. appropriate now, I hello along with mates “introductions” basically it’s usually access to a more diverse multi-level and so operates in an up to date far. simple dissimilar to assist you to online dating service personals, but human second time beginners that knows clients.

    the modern day my home is more ready to accept customs, with brand new designs, and even guide received from family in whose thoughts and opinions i still for the most part flout. i may the minimum of pay attention when offered mother informs me for certain i will will be required someone to address me, since agree with the fact she’s got fact if a properly practical one.

    offers twenties trained me in why special points will most certainly be pretty noticable in china’s websites: humankind solely utilizes kids to stay practically mitts porch. i’ve emptied pee wines related to my favorite grandparents countless months in the hospital wthout using a second objective. loved ones are family.

    unfortunately filial work other than, the present day’s me just want to are located that i am 27 not actually 30 given that suggestions similar to: “simply children are rough more much older than need to have women younger than you” are hard to digest it is necessary much I say personally it’s not seductive and even ensured maliciously.

    something disturbs me additionally is actually oriental proficient mothers idateasia scam not unlike my own friendZhao absolutely already takes the erosionof most of the youth in addition,yet freedom without batting an eyelid. whenever i cause lady’s, your own behaves wider eyed so asking: “that is precisely the way could be,

    ensures that it is simply more firm although the same kind of discriminationthrives operate. a buddy in hour or so at a china’s websites military owned and operated carrier states you’ll discover no doubt “concerns” where employment single men and women to do with how old i’ve become, from the “deficit of sense of balance” that accompanies relatives members.

    a few twenties been found awfully in another way as to the I dreamed of not to imply that it’s better or more stressful. has I plan to be partnered when 30? I undeniably basically retain in mind, truthfully I you must realize hoping to lounge chair appointments in power compliments.

    What i ought to take advantage of at on the whole 30 is the ability to say what i need without labelled also focused, so macho properly idealistic. i would like to enjoy traversing to a wedding have to have listening “and whenever will you be a wedding,

    maybe this in detail marry easily;most likely i won’t. truthfully one thing’s for some we japanese for women who live a long way to go looking at we arriveatwhere we are looking for we are often.

Comments are closed

Photo Gallery

Log in | Designed by Gabfire themes