Great plans for U-16 & U-20, but what after?
YOU
can't help but have only admiration for two
recent SLRFU decisions intended to give
greater thrust to junior development. At a
meeting a fortnight ago, jointly presided
over by DIG Nimal Lewke and Dr. K. A. D.
Punyadasa, presidents respectively of the
Union and the Schools Rugby Association, it
was decided to (1) establish an under16
national development pool and (2) launch an
under 20 Inter Provincial tournament.
Apparently, decision (1) is intended to
dovetail into decision (2), meaning the
under 16 development pool would serve as a
feeder of better talents to the seven under
20 teams that are to figure in the proposed
Inter Provincial - a competition of
countrywide representation, which, goes
without saying, would be the picking ground
for any national junior team, be it under
18, 19 or 20.
The ultimate objective, obviously, is to
establish a system that would yield stronger
and better-prepared national teams for the
yearly under 20 Junior Rugby Asiad, singly
the most important junior tournament in
Asia, being as it is the gateway to the
World Junior Championship.
Junior internationals
With the next Junior Asiad scheduled for
December in Korea, the Union and the SLSRFA
are determined to launch the under 20 Inter
Provincial within the next few months. As
well, the Union release, emanating from the
meeting of a fortnight ago, speaks of plans
to host one or two junior internationals,
hopefully against Hong Kong/Thailand/ or
Malaysia, this September/October.
It is, of course, too premature to say what
sort of impact the under 16 development pool
will have on the country's under 20 rugby -
an assessment that would be possible only
after the two initiatives have been up and
running for up to three-to-five seasons. As
blueprints go, though, it has to be regarded
as the most thoughtful plan ever conceived
for preparing the country's team for the
Junior Asiad.
Past preparations, bar the one undertaken
for the Colombo Junior Asiad in 2001 when we
qualified for the Junior World Championship,
has, at best, been ad hoc; an arrangement
cobbled together few weeks prior to the
event. The way Dr. Punyadasa described it;
as preparations go, the past ones were but
an apology for the sort actually required
before competing in Asia's supreme junior
rugby competition.
Asia's best
"The Junior Asiad is the most important
junior rugby tournament in the continent -
but our preparations didn't quite show we
were readying for such a serious event. We
approached it as if it were just another
tournament . a few trials, the squad
selected and then off to play against Asia's
best.
That's just not good enough," said Dr.
Punyadasa. "By getting an under 16
development pool going and conducting annual
Inter Provincial under 20 tournaments, we
hope that a continuing long-term preparation
for the Junior Asiad would've been
established - a sort of self-operating
system."
This plan, it has to be said, is an academic
masterpiece, though, only time will tell
whether the desired objectives would see the
light of day. My only criticism of it,
though, is that the plan doesn't speak, as
plans must, of a future beyond the Junior
Asiad. With the Union being co-author of
this blueprint, you'd expect mention of the
plan's intended influence on first division
and national rugby.
Different entities
But then, it will be argued, senior rugby
ought not to be entangled with the junior;
the two are different entities - to which,
some will respond: but for the dependence of
one on the other, there can be no future for
rugby.
Even so, for the sheer creativity of the
plan, applause is irresistible - except for
one restraint. Down the long years, we've
been swamped with all sorts of development
plans, all promising a better future for the
game. However, we soon learn that our rugby
has indeed changed, but not for the better.
All you have to do is look at the stands
depleting year-in-year-out to remind you of
division one rugby's sad decline.
Caltex, sponsors of first division
tournaments, made mention of its concerns
over one-sided competitions. The company's
CEO, Kishu Gomes, at the media launch of the
2008 league season, expressed the hope the
season would provide more competitive
matches, "not one-horse races" - so that
rugby might win back its once huge
spectator-following.
Clifford cup
It wasn't a complaint, but it is excusable
to think Gomes was disguising his
disappointment. After all, there's little to
please the sponsor when in seven long
seasons there hasn't been a change of
champions.
And over the past 15 years, the Clifford Cup
has as good as been willed to Kandy SC, who,
since 1992, has been winners for all but
only two seasons, in one of which they
weren't participants.
The 2008 season is already a month old, and
not far from concluding its eight-team round
one. And from the preface it seems as if
it's going to be the same old story of Kandy
SC dominance. The only worthy challenger
appears to be again the same old No.2, CR
&FC. Both remain undefeated.
Serious challenge
Police, it was thought, would present a
serious challenge this season, but alas,
Kandy SC last week overcame them 39/6, a
margin too big to encourage hopes of a
different outcome in their other meetings
this season. The Havelocks, the third
undefeated team, is being talked up as a
worthy challenger, but the real examination
of their strength is yet to come: v. Police,
Kandy SC, CR and CH.
The Park club might pull off a win or two
more, but as for wrenching the league trophy
from Kandy SC's clasp, well, that's as
remotely away as they are from their halcyon
years of the '60s through to the '80s.
Then, the public floggings handed Old
Zahirians is cruel - and seriously degrades
what is the country's premier domestic
tournament. These annihilations have given
the game a new method of measuring clubs'
strengths: a club incapable of posting
100-plus over OZRFC is unworthy of first
division status!
Noble principle
It's not the first time that OZRFC has been
reduced to whipping boys of first division
rugby. So, it begs the question why OZRFC
continues to be persevered with as a first
division team? The Union answer to
encourage first division ambitions among
other emerging teams.
It's a noble principle, but the problem is
life in the first division requires more
than encouraging words from the Union;
tangible support in terms of men and
material is required. But OZRFC receives no
more than the annual disbursement of Rs.100,
000 given other clubs too.
If the Union honestly wishes to improve the
quality of first division competition then
the new entrants need to be given greater
helping -both in terms of technical and
financial assistance. To expect OZRFC to
fend for themselves is pretty much leaving
the new-born among wolves. That's not
development.
Rubgy's top storey
This is where the master plan we spoke of
earlier is in gross contradiction of overall
development. This is not to say there is no
virtue in having an under 16 development
pool with links to an under 20 Inter
Provincial tournament so as to found a
system that would improve Junior Asiad
preparations.
Assuming the system is successful, it is
lovely to think that a batch of junior
players of high quality pedigree would
become available annually to first division
clubs. The reality, however, is a whole lot
starker. The number of first division clubs
is no more than what it was when much less
rugby was played at the junior level. Said
simply, presently there's no room in rugby's
top storey.
Consider the facts: 67 schools figure in the
three divisions of the Singer Schools
tournament. Add to those 97 "developing"
schools that compete in the seven provincial
tournaments. That makes a grand total 164
rugby-playing schools in the island.
The contrast
Contrast that with the numbers of some
three-four decades ago. You could count the
of rugby-playing schools with your fingers:
Trinity, Royal, S. Thomas,'St. Peter's, St.
Joseph's, Wesley, St. Anthony's Isipathana,
Thurstan and briefly Dharmasoka Ambalagoda;
10 in all.
The proliferation of rugby schools in Kandy
didn't happen until Kandy SC's dominance
began in the early '90s. And the provincial
spread began, also in the 1990s, with the
inauguration of provincial unions.
At the time when there were a handful of
rugby-playing schools, the number of clubs
available to the school-leavers was,
ironically, more than the present eight.
Then Colombo had CR, CH, and Havelocks and
for awhile, NCC; Up country: Kandy SC, Kandy
RFC, Dimbula, Dickoya, Uva and Kelani
Valley. Add the service teams - Army, Navy,
Air Force and the Police - and you had a
bounteous 14 first division clubs to absorb
the products of 10 schools.
Presently, there's far more supply than
demand: 164 rugby-playing schools: eight
first division clubs. That ratio reflects
eloquently the pathetic story of our rugby -
a tale of more schoolboy talent being lost
than absorbed to first division rugby.
The products of the under 16 development
pool and the Inter Provincial under 20
tournament are going to only compound the
frustration of the young players with no
clubs to play for. It's a malady that might
well kill off the game. Some creative rescue
plans on that score would be more useful,
Presidents Lewke and Punyadasa.
Rupasinghe: The talk of his US College
AMRIT Rupasinghe has turned in some
exceptional performances for Bates College
in the All-American Inter Collegiate
Division Three Men's Tennis Championship.
The 20-year-old Sri Lankan's first
noteworthy contribution was to help Bates,
in Maine, qualify for the All-American
Collegiate Div. 3 Championship - no mean
task given that 600 teams were in the race
for only 16 places. To add to Bates joy of
qualification, the All-American event was
held this year in their own backyard, in
Lewiston -so arousing tremendous enthusiasm
among the local population.
Reports on the website, Sunjournal.com,
mention of the presence of large crowds,
unseen before, cheering the Sri Lankan and
his doubles partner, Ben Stein.
Cliffhanger quarterfinal
The Bates pair won a cliffhanger
quarterfinal, which Sunjournal described
thus: "Down a set and a break, the Bates duo
found an extra gear in the second set,
forced a tiebreaker, and rode the momentum
swing - and the raucous crowd - to a 6/1 win
in the third set over Washington University
in Louis' Chris Hoeland and Charlie Cutler
to advance to the semi final."
The semifinal, however, brought less happy
tidings. The Sunjournal reports again: "The
Lewiston tennis community and what seemed
like half of the Bates College campus did
their best to push Ben Stein and Amrit
Rupasinghe into the national finals of the
Division III Men's Doubles Championships.
"But a pair of untimely breaks of serves
spelled the end of the duo's dynamic run.
"Andy Bryan and Charlie Paukert of Gustavus
Adolphus showed solid net play and resolve
enough to come back from an early break
against a hostile crowd to upend Stein and
Rupasinghe, 7-5, 6-4, to earn a place in the
final match,"
All American honours
Notwithstanding the semifinal elimination,
Sri Lankan Rupasinghe wrote his name into
the Bates' record books by being just one of
six in the College's history to win the
All-American honours - awarded for
outstanding individual performances in just
not tennis but all sports the College play.
As well, the successes in the All-American
Collegiate earned Rupasinghe and Stein No.1
spot in the North Eastern rankings.
Rupasinghe, an old boy of St. Thomas'
Kollupitiya, won a tennis scholarship to
Bates College in 2006. While vacationing
here last year, he found time to compete in
the National Championships - and walked off
with his first National Singles title.
His ambition is to represent Sri Lanka at
the Davis Cup. He, like Franklyn Emmanuel
and Oshada Wijemanne, wasn't available for
the 2008 Davis Cup in April owing to
examinations. "Normally, the Davis Cup is
held around July/August, and if next year it
falls into that time frame, Amrit says he'll
definitely give a shot at Davis Cup
selection, '' said a member of the
Rupasinghe family.
Outstanding youngsters
Rupasinghe, together with outstanding
youngsters Harshana Godamanna, Emmanuel,
Wijemanne, are products of a junior
development program initiated under the
presidency of Lalith Vitharna in 2000 and
placed in charge of Arjan Perera. The
programme was given further impetus through
greater investments during the 2002-07
presidency of Suresh Subramaniam.
Rupasinghe is likely to defend his singles
title at this August Nationals. A nice
opportunity is before the SLTA to spice up
this year's Nationals - by endeavoring to
bring down those talented US-based
youngsters to participate in the event. But
the problem is that the SLTA administration
is virtually pro-tem, awaiting a new date
from Sport Minister Gamini Lokuge to hold
the postponed 2008 AGM.
Ecstatic home crowd
It is hardly likely a lame duck
administration will be inclined to undertake
the not so small job of gingering the
Nationals with overseas players - not if
you've followed the way it has stumbled from
controversy to another, from selection rows
to a vanishing CEO to allegations of
commission-taking from ad firms.
Bates College's Ben Stein (Pelham, N.Y.) and
sophomore Amrit Rupasinghe (Colombo, Sri
Lanka) defeated Trinity University's Oliver
Gaines and Ryan DeSantis 6-4, 7-6 (3) Friday
in the Round of 16 of the NCAA Division III
Men's Tennis Doubles Championships in front
of an ecstatic home crowd at Bates' Wallach
Tennis Center.
Stein and Rupasinghe advanced to Saturday's
quarterfinals, where they will meet
Washington University duo Charlie Cutler and
Chris Hoeland, the No. 2 seed in the field.
By making the quarterfinals the Bobcat pair
secured All-America honors, becoming the
fifth and sixth Bates men's tennis
All-Americans.
Evenly matched
The match was quite evenly matched, with
only one game separating both throughout the
first set, until the Bobcats extended their
5-4 advantage to 6-4.
Gaines and DeSantis took Bates to a
tiebreaker in the second set, where the
Bobcats took immediate control, building a
5-2 lead. A service ace by Stein clinched
the victory for the home team, Bates' lone
representation at the six-day NCAA
Championships (Stein was the alternate from
the Northeast Region in the singles field.)
The quarter-finals and semi-finals of the
Singles Championship were slated for 9 a.m
and 12 p.m Saturday, followed by the doubles
quarter-finals at 3 p.m.
Sunday will feature the singles finals at 12
p.m, followed by the doubles semi-finals at
2 p.m and the doubles finals at 4 p.m.
Singles, Doubles fields narrowed
Seven out of eight seeds were eliminated
from the 32-player field Friday as the NCAA
Division III Men's Tennis Singles
Championship was reduced to eight players in
two rounds.
No. 1 seed John Watts of Washington
University in St. Louis advanced to
Saturday's quarter-finals with victories
over Jared Kamel of UC Santa Cruz and Andrew
Lee of Middlebury.
Watts will face Michael Klimchak of The College of New Jersey in
Saturday's quarter-finals, which begins at 9
a.m. The other quarter-final match-ups will
pit: Chris Fletcher of Methodist vs. Michael
Greenberg of Kenyon; Stephen Sullivan of
Bowdoin vs. Spencer Feldman of Trinity
(Conn.) College; and Charlie Cutler of
Washington University vs. Filip Marinkovic
of Middlebury College.
In the doubles play, Stein and Rupasinghe
will meet Cutler and Hoeland of the newly
minted NCAA team champion, the Bears of
Washington University in St. Louis.
Other quarter-final doubles matchups on
Saturday will pit Middlebury's Marinkovic
and Andrew Thomson vs. Andy Bryan and
Charlie Paukert of Gustavus Adolphus; UC
Santa Cruz's Kamel and Marc Vartabedian
against John Mook and Eddie Glidewell of
Christopher Newport; and Guillaume Schils
and Larry Wang of Claremont-Mudd-Scripps vs.
Randy Loden and Kaz Murata of Mary
Washington.
The quarter-finals and semi-finals of the
Singles Championship were slated for 9 a.m
and 12 p.m Saturday, followed by the doubles
quarter-finals at 3 p.m.
Sunday will feature the singles finals at 12
p.m, followed by the doubles semi-finals at
2 p.m and the doubles finals at 4 p.m.
Singles Round of 32 Scores
#1 John Watts (Washington-St. Louis) def.
Jared Kamel (UC-Santa Cruz), 7-5, 6-0
Andrew Lee (Middlebury) def. Mark Boren
(Emory), 7-5, 6-4
Michael Klimchak (TCNJ) def. John Kauss (Gustavus
Adolphus), 6-2, 6-0
John Mook (Christopher Newport) def. #8
Larry Wang (Claremont-M-S), 6-4, 7-5
Chris Fletcher (Methodist) def. #5 Garrett
Gates (Bowdoin), 6-4, 6-1
Cameron Taylor (Pomona-Pitzer) def. Kortney
Keith (DePauw), 6-7 (5), 6-3, 7-6 (6)
Michael Greenberg (Kenyon) def. James Furr
(Trinity-TX), 6-1, 6-0
Randy Loden (Mary Washington) def. #4 Dan
Greenberg (Williams), 6-2, 6-1
#3 Michael Goodwin (Emory) def. Eric Wagar
(Redlands), 7-6 (3), 6-2
Stephen Sullivan (Bowdoin) def. Miguel Yunes
(Carthage), 6-1, 6-2
Spencer Feldman (Trinity-CT) def. John
Pelton (Hope), 6-2, 3-6, 6-3
#6 Oliver Gaines (Trinity-TX) def. Brendan
Kincaid (Salisbury), 6-7 (4), 7-5, 3-3
(retired)
#7 John James (Mary Washington) def. Dustin
Phillips (Texas-Tyler), 1-6, 7-6 (4), 7-6
(4)
Charlie Cutler (Washington-St. Louis) def.
Zach Lerner (Amherst), 7-6 (5), 6-3
David Maldow (Johns Hopkins) def. Max Ortiz
(UC Santa Cruz), 6-3, 6-1
Filip Marinkovic (Middlebury) def. #2 Andy
Bryan (Gustavus Adolphus), 4-6, 6-2, 7-6 (3)
Singles Round of 16 Scores
#1 John Watts (Washington-St. Louis) def.
Andrew Lee (Middlebury), 6-2, 7-5
Michael Klimchak (TCNJ) def. John Mook
(Christopher Newport), 6-2, 6-2
Chris Fletcher (Methodist) def. Cameron
Taylor (Pomona-Pitzer), 6-3, 6-2
Michael Greenberg (Kenyon) def. Randy Loden
(Mary Washington), 6-4, 6-1
Stephen Sullivan (Bowdoin) def. #3 Michael
Goodwin (Emory), 7-6 (3), 6-2
Spencer Feldman (Trinity-CT) def. #6 Oliver
Gaines (Trinity-TX), 6-2, 6-2
Charlie Cutler (Washington-St. Louis) def.
#7 John James (Mary Washington), 6-1, 6-1
Filip Marinkovic (Middlebury) def. David
Maldow (Johns Hopkins), 6-7 (4), 6-3, 6-4
Doubles Round of 16
#1 Jared Kamel/Marc Vartabedian (UC Santa
Cruz) def. Michael Klimchak/Roger Mosteller
(TCNJ), 6-1, 7-5
John Mook/Eddie Glidewell (Christopher
Newport) def. Michael Greenberg/Jeremy
Polster (Kenyon), 7-6 (4), 7-5
Guillaume Schils/Larry Wang (Claremont-M-S)
def. Dan Greenberg/Bret Thacher (Williams)
6-3, 3-6, 6-4
#4 Randy Loden/Kaz Murata (Mary Washington)
def. Randy Lofgren/Kevin Newman (Denison),
7-6 (7), 6-4
Andy Bryan/Charlie Paukert (Gustavus
Adolphus) def. Dustin Phillips/David Ashlock
(Texas-Tyler), 6-2, 6-3
Ben Stein/Amrit Rupasinghe (Bates) def.
Oliver Gaines/Ryan DeSantis (Trinity-TX),
6-4, 7-6 (3)
#2 Charlie Cutler/Chris Hoeland
(Washington-St. Louis) def. Casey Blythe/Joe
Vasoontara (Johns Hopkins), 1-6, 6-3, 6-4
(TMKS)
Havies drub Police 22-12
Havelocks Sports Club produced a superb
second half rally to beat Sri Lanka Police
Sports Club by 22 points to 12 points in
their Caltex inter club A division league
rugby tournament match worked off at the
Police Park on Friday.
The Havies who took a close 7 nil lead at
half time produced an improved performance
in the second half to win the match by a
more convincing margin while collecting
their points from two goals, one try and one
penalty.
Police SC after a promising start failed to
maintain the same momentum and responded
with one goal and one try.
Prince of Wales in upset 24-11 win over
Ananda
Prince of Wales College, Moratuwa scored an
upset 24 points to 11 points victory over
the more fancied Ananda College team in
their Singer inter school under 20 Division
One Group B league rugby tournament match
played at Longden Place last Friday.
The Cambrians collected their points from
two goals and two tries after having led
12-3 at half time. Ananda College managed to
score just a solitary try and put over two
drop goals.
Thurstan
trounce Science College 42-0
Thurstan College routed Science College, Mount Lavinia by 42
points to nil in their Singer inter school
under 20 Division One Group B league rugby
tournament match worked off at Longden Place
on Friday.
Thurstan collected their points from three
goals, three tries and two penalties after
having led 13 nil at half time.
Wesley College in rousing 55-5 victory over
Lumbini
Wesley College powered their way to score a
rousing 55 points to 5 points victory over
Lumbini MV in their Singer inter school
under 20 Division One Group B league rugby
tournament match played at Havelock Park on
Friday.
The Wesleyites after having led 10-5 at half
time cut loose in the second half and
collected their points from five goals and
four tries. Lumbini MV managed to score just
a solitary try. |