While the government continued to adopt a
Jekyll and Hyde approach to human rights
violations, media freedom and good
governance issues in the face of mounting
concerns from the international community,
President Mahinda Rajapakse opened another
front last week by announcing provincial
council polls for the North Central and
Sabaragamuwa provinces heightening in the
process tensions in the political arena.
The timing of the dissolution was
indicative that the government was working
on the basis of a political road map for a
general election as early as November 2008
or even a presidential poll after November
2009 having secured victory in staggered
provincial polls and creating a perception
the administration’s popularity remained
high purely based on the propaganda hype
over the war.
Devastating
But in doing so, what the President has
done is stirred a hornet’s nest which could
have serious political ramifications
considering the devastating impact the
crumbling economy is having on the people
with inflation spiralling out of control and
the Supreme Court no less breathing fire
over salary increments.
For, elections cost a huge amount of
money which has to be met by the Treasury
not to mention the millions more that are
poured into the campaign, and at a time the
government says it has no money to meet the
salary demands of the judiciary, health,
education and other sectors the questions
that necessarily will be asked by the
affected groups is why the president is then
spending millions on unwarranted elections.
Unwarranted, it is argued because, both
the Sabaragamuwa and North Central provinces
have one year more of its term left and a
majority in both councils had in writing
informed their respective governors not to
dissolve the councils since there was no
threat to its majorities.
Crucial
Further, neither council had been
defeated in any crucial vote, or in passing
their respective budgets, which again begs
the question of why they were dissolved at a
time the country and its people are
undergoing terrible economic hardships.
These factors no doubt will be not lost
on the chief justice or the unions agitating
for wage increments with Opposition Leader
Ranil Wickremesinghe weighing in on the
issue, calling the dissolution a move to
distract the people from the pressing
problems they were facing.
Wickremesinghe was quoted on Thursday as
telling journalists that the dissolution of
the councils or holding elections is no
solution to the crisis gripping the country
today at a time the rate of inflation has
gone upto 30 per cent and he proceeded to
outline the controversies relating to Grade
1 school admissions, teachers salary issue,
that in the health sector and the SLFP being
replaced by family politics.
Nose dive
Interestingly, even as Wickremesinghe
spoke there was an e-mail doing the rounds
with the photograph of a nose-diving Mihin
Lanka aircraft and a number of highlights
which were right on the button when it came
to economic mismanagement by the government.
The graphic spoke of Mihin incurring a
loss of three billion rupees in one year of
operation with the government having pumped
in a colossal Rs. 3.1 billion for the
airline’s survival and then proceeds to
state that the money could have been used to
provide 1000 buses for public transport, 100
railway coaches, give Samurdhi benefits to
500,000 more people, reduce the price of
rice and make available fuel at a cheaper
price for three wheeler drivers.
Effective as it is, that simple message
spoke volumes on the government’s economic
mismanagement now compounded by two further
provincial polls at a time none were
required.
Mind you, it was only two weeks back,
President Rajapakse in his capacity as
finance minister personally submitted a
cabinet memorandum outlining tough economic
measures to face the fuel crisis which
included curtailing the importation of
vehicles for one year, stopping the entry of
vehicles to the city one day each week and
pruning the fuel allowances of public
servants as cost cutting and fuel saving
measures which were also impacting on
foreign exchange reserves.
Gloomy
Having painted a gloomy economic scenario
the President goes and calls for two
provincial elections, where no doubt the
full might of the government machinery
including vehicles will be used, burning
fuel by the hundreds of gallons whilst on
the other hand calling on the people to
tighten their belts. And it is in that
context the ‘conspiracy theory’ of the chief
justice in open court last week also
attracts credence.
The only respite the government has so
far had is from the opposition which apart
from some poorly organised demonstrations
have not really put the administration to
the sword, although the JVP is now showing
signs of it once again coming of age with
some imaginative poster and protest
campaigns signalling tougher days ahead for
the Rajapakse regime.
Evident
It is in this context that the UNP is now
attempting to put a broad front together
with like-minded parties such as the SLFP
(M), SLMC and Mano Ganeshan’s (WPPF) for
starters. And a sign of things to come was
evident at the New Town Hall on Thursday,
when both the UNP Leader Ranil
Wickremesinghe and SLFP Patron Chandrika
Kumaratunga made their appearance for the
SLFP (M) inaugural convention where stirring
speeches were made on the crisis confronting
the country.
Significantly, Kumaratunga making her
first public appearance on a political
platform after relinquishing office showed
she has not lost her touch when it came to
the party and thrust of politics, going so
far as to pledge support for a broad
alliance to face the challenges confronting
the country.
In words which would no doubt rankle the
Rajapakse brothers, Kumaratunga had this to
say on the state of the nation: "When a
country’s people are denied their basic
freedom, its society faces serious
impediments in its forward march in a
responsible, independent manner, we all know
that the outcome of such a situation
adversely affects the economy.’
And then comes the biting comment: "If
the government does not have a correct
efficient and timely economic plan in place,
the economy suffers further. Furthermore, if
there is rampant corruption in the
administration, a handful will steal the
public resources and become rich, while the
others become poorer."
Not stopping at that, Kumaratunga also
had a message for the SLFP, calling for the
party to tread a moderate path with thuggery
and corruption eliminated whilst also urging
an extensive people’s dialogue within the
blues.
In purely political terms, for Rajapakse,
this political developments will be cause
for worry as he knows Kumaratunga can rock
the boat for him from within and with the
party base, especially in the all-important
Gampaha District, which opportunity the
opposition of course can capitalise on.
That from an opposition point of view is
a positive development but for a concerted
campaign to bear fruit where the UNP lead
broad front and the JVP march separately and
strike together the Greens, have to put its
own house in order first with rumblings
heard from Sri Kotha to Cambridge Terrace as
some members position themselves to fish in
troubled waters.
Tragedy
That unfortunately is the tragedy of Sri
Lanka and at a time the people are
undergoing immense suffering another power
struggle in the main opposition would be
manna from heaven for the Rajapakse regime
and it is up to both the UNP leader
Wickremesinghe and those members wanting
party reforms to sit down, thrash the
contentious issues and reach a compromise
lest the wrath of the people be turned on
them for the greatest betrayal of all.
For, the opposition message of economic
chaos and despotic rule will find little
resonance with the people from a house
divided and needless to say, not help
mobilise the public for a concerted campaign
either because they will not want to risk
throwing their weight in such an
environment.
Democracy
Ironically, in the absence of a
concerted, well-coordinated opposition
campaign, it is the international community
that has been the torchbearer for democracy,
human rights and media freedom in Sri Lanka
as was once again reflected during the visit
of the European Commission delegation last
week.
Given the economic crisis confronting the
country, the GSP plus facility from the
European Union is crucial not just for Sri
Lanka but the very survival of the
government given the fact, nearly one
million jobs both direct and indirect and
over US$ one billion in export earning ride
on it, and with that sword of Damocles
hanging over the Rajapakse regime, they are
forced to sit up and take notice on the
calls for human rights protection, media
freedom and democracy.
Haunt
It was in fact Mahinda Rajapakse who in
1990 called on donors to link aid to human
rights and democracy, a call which has now
come to haunt him given the utterances of
his own Defence Secretary brother, Gotabaya
Rajapakse, which the European Commission has
obviously taken note of as reflected in the
comments made by head of delegation External
Relations, Deputy Director General Joao
Agular Machado in Colombo last week at a
press conference.
Prior to the press conference the EC
delegation who were here for the EC — Sri
Lanka Joint Commission meeting met with
International Trade Minister, G. L. Peiris,
Human Rights Minister Mahinda Samarasinghe,
UPFA National List MP, Basil Rajapakse and
Foreign Secretary Palitha Kohona where the
importance of addressing the human rights
situation, threats to the media and
disarming para military groups amongst other
subjects were raised.
Discussion
Minister Peiris for his part attempted to
explain the current situation in the country
from an academic perspective, spinning his
own theories to make sure Sri Lanka
qualifies for the GSP plus, which however
attracted little currency with the EC
delegation, though a more insightful
discussion was had with minister Mahinda
Samarasinghe, where Attorney General C. R.
De Silva, Human Rights Secretary, Rajiva
Wijesinha and Sri Lanka’s Ambassador to the
EU, Ravinath Ariyasinha were also present.
At this meeting the five-member EC
delegation which included Machado and
Ambassador Julian Wilson discussed specifics
on the human rights front and the progress
made including the threats faced by the
media with particular reference to
abductions and open threats and incitement
to violence against journalists.
Human rights
There was of course praise for the
government with regard to the Witness and
Victims Protection Bill which Minister
Samarasinghe said would be introduced in
Parliament on June 19 whilst Wijesinha
explained steps taken to train the police
when dealing with human rights issues and
persons arrested.
That said, several were the concerns
expressed by the EC delegations with
specific attention also drawn to the
implementation of the 17th Amendment to the
Constitution, which provides for the
Constitutional Council and independent
commissions.
Of course, it was not the mandate of the
EC delegation to tell the government it will
not qualify for the GSP plus unless the
issues raised are addressed before the
review process takes effect but that was the
unspoken message which was not lost on the
administration.
Aware
And Minister Samarasinghe sought to
deflect the query on the 17th Amendment
implementation by adverting to the select
committee process now underway on reviewing
the amendment but that explanation though
noted found little acceptance, with the
delegation all too aware it was nothing more
than a delaying tactic for the President to
forge ahead with all key appointments in the
public sector, police, judiciary, human
rights commission whilst holding back on the
independent elections commission.
That apart, the EC delegation also
queried the progress made with regard to the
number of service and police personnel
prosecuted and convicted for human rights
violations which saw the Attorney General
citing the figure of 599.
No doubt, taken by surprise, the EC
delegation asked whether 599 personnel were
indicted in the recent past which saw the
Attorney General explaining that the figure
was for a period of 20 years.
More
With a wry smile, head of the EC
delegation Machado at that point asked for
more specific information on the subject
which the government delegation agreed to
provide.
Not stopping at that, the EC delegation
asked what progress was made with regard to
the 16 cases listed for inquiry before the
commission of inquiry including the killing
of the Trincomalee students and the aid
workers massacre and the government’s
response was again found wanting though the
Attorney General did his best to give a
positive spin to it.
The Attorney General said since the
commission of inquiry is still going through
the cases, the Attorney General’s Department
is not hoping to do anything by way of
indicting until the COI reports are
submitted. That could of course go well into
next year, by which time the GSP plus will
be long gone.
Disarmed
And the government’s failure to disarm
all para military groups was also noted
especially in the backdrop of Human Rights
Secretary and Peace Secretarial Chief Rajiva
Wijesinha stating the government has no
intention of doing so until the LTTE is
disarmed.
Of course, Foreign Secretary Palitha
Kohona attempted to diffuse the issue by
stating the government position is that no
group is allowed to bear arms other than the
security forces and police but it found
little resonance considering the fact that
the official Defence Ministry website, no
less posting Wijesinha’s comments, thus
giving it the stamp of credibility and
making it a policy statement.
Response
On the issue of para militaries, this is
what Wijesinha had to say in response to a
call made by the religious superiors of the
Conference of Major Religious Superiors:
"Again the superiors ask the necessary
steps be taken ‘to stop para military groups
functioning in the north and east and to
disarm them." It is not clear whether this
request is addressed to the LTTE too, the
para military group par excellence; which
decimated all other Tamil groups; more
easily when they were disarmed in 2002,
following the ceasefire agreement. Even at
the request of the Superiors, there is no
way the government of Sri Lanka is going to
betray Tamils who stood out against the LTTE,
to allow them to be slaughtered. Certainly
the Superiors would ask that all those
including the LTTE stop functioning as para
military groups, and enter a democratic
political process, following the example of
the most Catholic group of all, the Irish
Republican Army, which finally agreed to
decommission arms so that peace could be
pursued. The singling out of more vulnerable
groups is however insidious, given that the
religious superiors cannot be ignorant of
the bloodshed to which earlier selective
disarming led."
Clear
Thus Wijesinha speaking for the
"Government of Sri Lanka" makes it clear
para military groups will not be disarmed
until the LTTE too does likewise even though
the Pillayan groups claims to have entered
the democratic process while Kohona also
speaking for the government says just the
opposite.
The only difference of course is that
Kohona’s statement on the issue was not
posted in the defence Ministry website while
Wijesinha’s was.
And that the EC delegation did not buy
into the government’s spin doctoring or this
Jekyll and Hyde approach was reflected at
their press conference, Thursday afternoon
where with particular reference to the GSP
plus facility, Machado had this to say – "
In order for Sri Lanka to be in the EU
preference list, we need the country’s
assistance."
Couched in diplomatic language, the
message of the EC delegation was that the
government would have to address the good
governance, human rights and media freedom
issues in addition to the ratification and
effective implementation of 27 international
conventions, mind you not according to
theory espoused by Minister G. L. Peiris but
in practice.
Machado was to also say thus: "In
meetings held with the Sri Lankan government
on Tuesday, we expressed our serious concern
over certain violations of human rights in
the island. Abductions and threats to media
personnel were among the major concerns."
Not satisfied
That the head of the EC delegation deemed
it necessary to reiterate these points after
meeting with the government was the surest
sign they were far from satisfied with
government’s responses that all was honky
dory.
And to emphasise the EC was not alone in
raising these issues, Machado was to say,
"It is not fair to portray these as an EU
obsession when many Asian nations have also
expressed concern."
It did not make the government’s case any
easier when the UN group on enforced or
involuntary disappearances announced on
Wednesday June 11 it has formally
communicated its concerns to the Sri Lanka
authorities that over the last two months,
22 people have disappeared, 18 of them in
May.
Targeted
"The works group is also concerned that
both women and humanitarian aid workers are
being targeted," the experts had said in a
statement just 48 hours before the general
assembly of the UN Human Rights Council was
to take up Sri Lanka’s case up for review in
Geneva.
The Geneva session for which Minister
Samarasinghe despatched his Secretary Rajiva
Wijesinha will see the Universal Periodic
Review of Sri Lanka tabled on May 13 taken
up for discussion where the government had
accepted 45 recommendations made by the
council in addition to a number of voluntary
pledges.
This report was to be put to the General
Assembly on Friday where Sri Lanka will have
20 minutes to speak with a further twenty
minutes each to the General Assembly members
and INGO’s and NGO’s and it remains to be
seen whether Sri Lanka will come out
unscathed.
Focus
But one thing is for sure, and that is
Sri Lanka is very much the focus in the
international arena on human rights issues
and if the likes of Gotabaya Rajapakse
continues with his gung ho style, it is the
public at large that will have to pay the
price for it, and some day that very public
will look to Gotabaya for redress. Be he in
Sri Lanka or the United states.